John M. Carland
U.S. Army in Vietnam
CMH Pub 91-5, Cloth; CMH Pub 91-5-1,
Paper
2000; 410 pages, illustrations, maps, tables,
bibliographical note, index
GPO S/N: 008-029-00354-6, Cloth; GPO
S/N: 008-029-00355-4, Paper
Combat Operations: Stemming the Tide describes a critical chapter in
the Vietnam conflict, the first eighteen months of combat by the U.S.
Army's ground forces. Relying on official American and enemy primary
sources, John M. Carland focuses on initial deployments and early
combat and takes care to present a well-balanced picture by discussing
not only the successes but also the difficulties endemic to the entire
effort. This fine work presents the war in all of its detail: the
enemy's strategy and tactics, General William C. Westmoreland's search
and destroy operations, the helicopters and airmobile warfare, the
immense firepower American forces could call upon to counter Communist
control of the battlefield, the out-of-country enemy sanctuaries, and
the allied efforts to win the allegiance of the South Vietnamese
people to the nation's anti-Communist government. Carland's volume
demonstrates that U.S. forces succeeded in achieving their initial
goals, but unexpected manpower shortages made Westmoreland realize
that the transition from stemming the tide to taking the offensive
would take longer. Bruising battles with the Viet Cong and North
Vietnamese in the Saigon area and in the Central Highlands had halted
their drive to conquest in 1965 and, with major base development
activities afoot, a series of high-tempo spoiling operations in 1966
kept them off balance until more U.S. fighting units arrived in the
fall. Carland credits the improvements in communications and
intelligence, the helicopter's capacity to extend the battlefield, and
the availability of enormous firepower as the potent ingredients in
Westmoreland's optimism for victory, yet realizes that the ultimate
issue of how effective the U.S. Army would be and what it would
accomplish during the next phase was very much a question mark.